Plymouth Rock Insurance logo

844-242-3555

Search

Find answers quickly for claims, billing, and more.

Olean, New York Auto Insurance

Get an auto insurance quote quickly

Please enter your zip code
Call for a quote 800-516-9242
Find an Agent
Continue your quote

Find an agent  |  Continue your quote

Reliable coverage for all the roads ahead

As a resident of Olean, the largest city in Cattaraugus County, New York, we understand that dependable auto insurance coverage is essential. That’s why drivers throughout the Northeast have trusted Plymouth Rock for 40+ years.

Plymouth Rock Assurance doesn’t promise reliability, we deliver it. No one plans to hit a bump on Route 417, so when the unexpected happens, we step into action. A Crashbusters® Mobile Claims Service van can drive to your location of choice and appraise the damage. This, and other convenient, customer-first services, is what makes us unique (along with helping you save an average of $702* on car insurance).

Ready to make the switch? Get started with a free quote.

Car insurance discounts and benefits

 

Paid in full discount

For eligible drivers when they pay their premium up front.
 

New driver family discount

Adding a new driver under the age of 19 to your policy? You may be eligible for a discount.
 

Bundling discounts

Save money when you have multiple insurance policies, such as auto and homeowners, with Plymouth Rock.
See all discounts

Coverage options available

Compulsory coverage

  • Bodily injury liability
  • Bodily injury caused by an uninsured auto
  • Damage to someone else's property
  • Personal Injury Protection (PIP)

Optional coverage

  • Collision
  • Comprehensive
  • Substitute transportation
  • Towing and labor
View all coverage options

Auto insurance resources

Young couple sitting on a sofa reviewing their insurance on their laptop

What is the minimum auto insurance coverage in New York?

8 minute read • August 2025

Father and daughter taking photos os damage to their car with a smart phone

What does no fault insurance NY cover?

6 minute read • October 2025

traffic driving away from New York City on Brooklyn Bridge

How to get car insurance in NY

7 minute read • October 2025

Piggy bank on dashboard of a car with stearing wheel partially in view

How Much is Car Insurance in New York?

7 minute read • November 2025

View more resources

Download our mobile app

The smarter way to manage your policy. 

  • View ID cards
  • Report and manage claims quickly 
  • Set up payments 
  • Update your policy 
QR Code

Scan the QR code to
download the app.

Mobile app

Drivers who switch to Plymouth Rock save an average of $702*

Get quote

Perks that hit it out of the park

Being a sports fan has its perks! Save on home game tickets, get priority access to concerts and events, and enjoy special discounts.

New York
Yankees

Yankees Logo

Join our Pinstripe
Perks program!

Explore benefits